Personal Loan vs. Credit Card for Holiday Expenses: Which Costs Less?
Holiday travel, gifts and hosting can add up to more than one month's budget. If you'll need a few months to pay it off, how you borrow matters as much as how much you spend. A credit card is the easy default, but it's often the most expensive way to carry a balance. A personal loan or a 0% introductory card can cost far less, if you use it the right way.
Here's what $5,000 of holiday expenses costs with each option.
The three options
Credit card: flexible and already in your wallet. You choose how much to pay each month above the minimum, but interest builds on whatever balance you carry.
Personal loan: a fixed amount at a fixed rate, repaid in equal monthly payments over a set term, often 12 to 60 months. Rates depend on your credit, and some lenders charge an origination fee.
0% intro APR card: a new credit card that charges no interest on purchases for an introductory period, often 12 to 21 months. After that, the regular rate applies to whatever is left.
What $5,000 costs with each
Credit card at 24.99% APR
Paying $200 a month: paid off in 36 months, about $2,135 in interest.
Paying $250 a month: paid off in 27 months, about $1,535 in interest.
Paying $150 a month: it takes 58 months, almost five years, and about $3,622 in interest.
Personal loan at 12.99% APR
24 months, no origination fee: about $238 a month and $704 in interest.
36 months, no origination fee: about $168 a month and about $1,064 in interest.
24 months with a 5% origination fee: to receive $5,000 you'd borrow about $5,263, so about $250 a month and roughly $1,005 in total cost (interest plus the fee).
At about the same monthly payment as the card at $250, the 24-month personal loan costs about $530 to $830 less, depending on the fee. Compared with paying the card at $150 a month, it finishes almost three years sooner.
0% intro APR card for 15 months
Paying $334 a month: the $5,000 is paid off in 15 months with no interest.
Paying $200 a month: about $2,000 is still owed when the intro period ends. At 24.99% after that, it takes another 12 months and about $266 in interest.
A 0% intro card is the cheapest option if you can pay most of the balance within the intro period and you qualify for one. Introductory offers usually need good to excellent credit.
How to choose
A personal loan fits if...
you need more than a few months to pay it off
you want a fixed payment and a firm finish date
your credit gets you a rate well below your card's APR
the lender charges no origination fee, or a small one
A 0% intro card fits if...
you can pay off all or most of the balance within the intro period
you have the credit to qualify
you'll stop using it for new spending once the holidays are over
Your current credit card fits if...
you'll pay the full balance within a month or two
the amount is small enough that the interest stays low
Tips before you borrow for the holidays
Set the payoff date first. Decide how many months you'll take, then work out the monthly payment. If it doesn't fit, it's a sign to spend less rather than borrow longer.
Compare the total cost, not the rate. An origination fee can make a low-rate loan cost more than it looks. Compare APRs, which include fees, and the total you'll repay.
Check your rate without a hard inquiry. Many lenders let you see a rate with a soft credit check, which doesn't affect your score.
Don't run the card back up. If you use a personal loan to pay off a card, keep the card balance at zero. Otherwise you end up with both debts.
Automate the payments. A late payment on either a loan or a card can mean fees and a hit to your credit score.
Run your own numbers
Enter the amount, rate and term from any loan offer in our personal loan calculator to see the monthly payment and total interest. If the holidays have already landed on several cards, our debt payoff calculator shows the fastest way to clear them.
Frequently asked questions
Is a personal loan cheaper than a credit card?
Often, yes. Personal loan rates are usually lower than credit card rates for the same borrower, and the fixed term stops the balance from lingering. A large origination fee can narrow the gap, so compare the total cost.
Does a personal loan hurt your credit score?
Applying usually causes a hard inquiry, which can lower your score slightly for a short time. On-time payments then build your credit history. Checking your rate with a soft inquiry first doesn't affect your score.
What is an origination fee?
It's a one-time charge some lenders take for setting up a personal loan, usually a percentage of the loan amount. It's often taken out of the money you receive, so you may need to borrow a little more to end up with the amount you need.
What happens when a 0% intro APR period ends?
Any balance left over starts to collect interest at the card's regular APR from that point. Unlike deferred-interest store offers, a true 0% intro APR doesn't charge interest for the months already passed.
The examples are for illustration only, with rounded figures, and are not financial advice. Your lender's or card issuer's terms decide your actual payments, interest and fees.
>