0% APR vs. Cash Rebate: Which Car Deal Saves More?
During year-end sales events, automakers often put two offers on the same car: 0% financing, or a few thousand dollars of cash back. You usually can't have both, so you have to pick. The 0% sounds unbeatable, but the rebate is real money off the price. Which one saves more depends on one number: the interest rate you could get on a regular car loan.
Here's how to work it out, with an example you can copy for any car.
How the two offers work
0% APR: the automaker's finance company lends you the money interest-free. You pay the full price, spread over the loan term. These offers are usually for buyers with excellent credit, and the term is often shorter than a regular loan, such as 36 or 48 months.
Cash rebate: the price drops by the rebate amount. You then pay cash, or finance the rest with a regular loan from a bank, credit union or the dealer at a normal rate.
The example: a $38,000 car
You're buying a $38,000 car with a $5,000 down payment. The dealer offers either 0% APR for 60 months or $3,000 cash back. To keep things simple, we leave out sales tax and fees.
Option 1: 0% APR for 60 months
Amount borrowed: $33,000
Monthly payment: $550
Interest: $0
Total paid on the loan: $33,000
Option 2: $3,000 rebate, loan at 4.9% for 60 months
Say your credit union offers 4.9% APR.
Amount borrowed: $30,000
Monthly payment: about $565
Interest: about $3,886
Total paid on the loan: about $33,886
The 0% offer wins by about $886. If your best loan rate were 6.5% instead, the rebate loan would cost about $35,219 in total, and the 0% offer would win by about $2,219.
The break-even rate
For any pair of offers, there's an interest rate at which they cost exactly the same. Below that rate the rebate wins; above it, the 0% offer wins.
In our 60-month example, the break-even rate is about 3.8%. Unless you can borrow at less than 3.8%, take the 0% financing.
Why a shorter 0% term changes the answer
Now say the 0% offer is only for 36 months:
0% APR, 36 months: $33,000 borrowed, about $917 a month, $33,000 in total.
$3,000 rebate, 4.9% for 36 months: $30,000 borrowed, about $898 a month, about $32,320 in total.
Here the rebate wins by about $680, and it also has the lower payment. Over 36 months, the break-even rate rises to about 6.3%. A short loan gives interest less time to add up, so the rebate gets more attractive.
Check the monthly payment as well. A 0% loan over 36 months can cost hundreds of dollars a month more than a longer regular loan, even if it saves money overall.
When the rebate is usually the better deal
You're paying cash. With no loan, there's no interest to save, so the rebate is pure savings.
You have a low rate from a bank or credit union, below the break-even rate for the offer.
The 0% term is short and you'd rather have a lower payment over a longer loan.
You plan to pay the loan off early, for example with a bonus or the sale of another car. The sooner you repay, the less interest the regular loan costs.
When 0% APR is usually the better deal
Your credit qualifies you for the promotion, and the loan rates you've been offered elsewhere are higher than the break-even rate.
The 0% term is long enough that the payment fits your budget.
The rebate is small compared with the amount you're borrowing.
Four things to check before you choose
Get a loan preapproval first. You can't find the break-even without knowing the rate you'd get elsewhere.
Agree on the price before mentioning the offer. A 0% deal shouldn't come with a higher price or less for your trade-in.
Ask how the rebate is taxed. In many states, sales tax is charged on the price before a manufacturer rebate, which slightly reduces what it's worth.
Read the qualification terms. If you don't qualify for the 0% rate, the dealer may offer a higher rate instead, so compare again.
Run your own numbers
Enter both offers in our auto loan calculator: the full amount at 0%, then the amount after the rebate at your bank's rate. Compare the total paid. To see the two loans side by side, use our loan comparison tool.
Frequently asked questions
Can I get both 0% APR and a cash rebate?
Usually not. Automakers typically make you choose one or the other on a given model, although some sales events combine a smaller rebate with a low rate. Ask the dealer which offers can be combined.
Who qualifies for 0% financing?
Promotional 0% rates are usually reserved for buyers with excellent credit. The lender decides, so get a preapproval elsewhere first in case you don't qualify.
Is a cash rebate taxable income?
A manufacturer rebate on a car you buy is generally treated as a reduction in price, not income. How sales tax applies to the rebate depends on your state.
What is the break-even interest rate?
It's the loan rate at which the rebate and the 0% offer cost the same in total. If you can borrow below that rate, take the rebate; if not, the 0% offer saves more.
The examples are for illustration only, with rounded figures, and are not financial or tax advice. Your actual price, rate, taxes and fees decide what you pay.
>